Home Entertainment Hip Fractures: Hip Protectors No Help?

Hip Fractures: Hip Protectors No Help?


July 24, 2007 — When elders fall, they may not be less likely to sustain a hip break in the event that they’re wearing a hip protector, a unused ponder appears.

“We were unable to distinguish a protective effect” against hip fractures in nursing domestic inhabitants matured 65 and older who wore hip protectors, the researchers note.

However, a diary editorial notes that there are several distinctive sorts of hip protectors and that more thinks about are required to see whether hip protectors do — or do not — prevent hip fractures in older grown-ups.

The study and editorial show up in the July 25 version of The Diary of the American Therapeutic Affiliation.

Hip Defender Ponder

The unused think about on hip protectors comes from researchers counting Douglas Kiel, MD, MPH.

Kiel is the director of therapeutic inquire about for the Established for Maturing Inquire about at Hebrew SeniorLife and Harvard Restorative School in Boston.

Kiel and colleagues examined 1,042 people matured 65 and more seasoned at 37 U.S. nursing homes. Participants were 85 a long time ancient, on normal. Most were white women; few were taking osteoporosis drugs. None were on bed rest when the ponder started.

Members wore extraordinary underpants with a built-in hip protector on their right or left hip. The hip defender included padding and a hard polyethylene shield.

The researchers visited the nursing homes to create beyond any doubt the residents were wearing their hip defenders and to track participants’ hip breaks.

Participants were followed for nearly eight months, on normal. During that time, hip fractures influenced generally 3% of the secured and unprotected hips, concurring to the think about.

Hip Protectors: Moment Opinion

The hip protector used in Kiel’s think about isn’t currently on the showcase. Since the think about begun, other hip defenders have gotten to be available and are being tried, Kiel’s team notes.

Kiel and colleagues note a few conceivable outcomes that might have influenced the study’s results.

Participants may have been more cautious to avoid falling during the study. They may moreover have attempted to land on their secured hip if they begun to fall, the researchers point out.

In addition, wearing a hip protector only on one hip may have influenced participants’ stride and hazard of falling, agreeing to the consider.

The data are “useful” but “not adequate” for assessing all hip protectors, note editorialist Pekka Kannus, MD, PhD, and colleagues.

Within the journal, the editorialists note money related ties to different wellbeing care companies. The analysts who worked on the consider report no budgetary conflicts of intrigued.